In 1989, after Craig proposes marriage to Samantha, the upcoming nuptials bring out old rivalries as Samantha must choose between marrying Craig, or staying with Will. Meanwhile, Will pays the ultimate price for the one crime he did commit when FBI agents approach him to force them to take down Craig's unscrupulous father. Aaron returns from Seattle with a secret, and Jenna puts her own acting career ahead of Carla's who's now involved in helping the Phillips with their marriage when she discovers that Paul Phillips is a domestic abuser who hits his wife, Meghan, whenever he's in a bad mood. Back in 2006, Detective Marjorino learns he's carried a grudge against the wrong man for 20 years when Will tells him about taking the fall for Craig's drunk driving accident that killed his father. Also, Carla receives an anonymous letter... from someone who claims to know who the murderer is.